Name	Known for
Russell Williams II Commentator Commentator See fewer	Dances with Wolves (1990)
Edward M. Kelahan Dave Neese Dave Neese See fewer	My Super Ex-Girlfriend (2006)
Shelia Eddy Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer
Geoff Edgers Commentator Commentator See fewer	Violin Thief
Shaun Irving Detective Detective See fewer	TURN: Washington's Spies (2014)
Missy Merry Skylar Neese (as Melissa Merry) Skylar Neese (as Melissa Merry) See fewer	Satanic Hispanics (2022)
Skylar Neese Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer
Erin Nordseth Patricia Shoaf Patricia Shoaf See fewer	Dawn (II) (2018)
Erin Rose Shelia Eddy Shelia Eddy See fewer	Boston Strangler (2023)
Rachel Shoaf Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer
Brian Stivale Narrator Narrator See fewer	Wizards take Flight (2021)
Maggie Tehan Rachel Shoaf Rachel Shoaf See fewer	The Midnight Matinee (2017)