I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco - Production & Contact Info

I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2026)
TV-14
TV Movie | 88 min | Biography, Drama

Primary photo for I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco

I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2026)

TV-14

TV Movie | 88 min | Biography, Drama

For the first time ever, Mary Jo Buttafuoco tells her story in her own words. In May 1992, outside her Long Island home, Mary Jo was shot in the head by 17-year-old Amy Fisher - the mistress of her husband, Joey Buttafuoco.

Director

Heather Hawthorn Doyle

Writer

Gregg McBride (written by)

Producer

Bruce Harvey (producer)

Composer

Mario Vaira

Cinematographer

Diego Lozano

Editor

Saeed Vahidi

Casting

Megan Bayliss (casting director) | Rebecca Davidson (casting director) | Deborah George (casting director)

Production Designer

Jim Cliffe (production designer)

See all filmmakers & crew

Become a member to see MOVIEmeter and news information about I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco.

Edit Released

Updated Jan 17, 2026

Release date

Jan 17, 2026 (United States)

Awards

2 nominations

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco.

Cast	+ Add Cast
30 cast members

Name	Known for
Leanne Allen Reporter Reporter See fewer	Recipes for Connection (2024)
Dillon Casey Joey Buttafuoco Joey Buttafuoco See fewer	BlackBerry (2023)
Easten Dacosta Paul Buttafuoco Paul Buttafuoco See fewer	Mother's Stolen Memories (2023)
Paisley Dacosta Jessica Buttafuoco Jessica Buttafuoco See fewer	I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2026)
Wesla English News Reporter News Reporter See fewer	The Killing (2011)
Michael Esposito II Young Adult Paul Buttafuoco Young Adult Paul Buttafuoco See fewer	Adult Adoption (2022)
Carly Fawcett Eileen Eileen See fewer	Cradle of Deception (2024)
Emma Forth Mary Jo Mary Jo See fewer	Freddy (2018)
Shay Galor Nosy Woman Nosy Woman See fewer	Kung Fu (2021)
Damon Gregory Judge Judge See fewer	Texas Two-Step (2026)
Shiraine Haas-Blake Rehab Nurse Rehab Nurse See fewer	A Million Little Things (2018)
Chardonnay Hanna Young Adult Jessie Young Adult Jessie See fewer	Watson (2024)
Maddy Hillis Amy Fisher Amy Fisher See fewer	Painkiller (2023)
Jonas Janz Peter Peter See fewer	Sweeter Than Chocolate (2023)
Chloe Lanier Mary Jo Buttafuoco Mary Jo Buttafuoco See fewer	Kingdom (2014)
Indy Lesage Steven Steven See fewer	Private Eyes West Coast
Curtis Lovell Hollywood Exec Hollywood Exec See fewer	Tron: Ares (2025)
Mark Maxson Juror Juror See fewer	Paycheck (2003)
Annaston Munro High School Mary Jo High School Mary Jo See fewer	Mormon Mom Gone Wrong: The Ruby Franke Story (2024)
Dayleigh Nelson Lead Cop Lead Cop See fewer	Arrow (2012)
Jayden Oniah Young boy Young boy See fewer	Final Destination: Bloodlines (2025)
Thane Ramsay High School Joey High School Joey See fewer	I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2026)
Tiffany Rice Maternity Nurse Maternity Nurse See fewer	My Bloody Bachelorette (2015)
Vincent Ross ER Doctor ER Doctor See fewer	A Vineyard Christmas (2023)
Amara Sanoy Jessica Buttafuoco Jessica Buttafuoco See fewer	Surviving My Father: The Rachel Jeffs Story (2025)
Ali Seifi Dr. Babak Azizzadeh Dr. Babak Azizzadeh See fewer	Legends of Tomorrow (2016)
Benjamin J Stevens Amy's New Lawyer Amy's New Lawyer See fewer	Bonds Will Be Broken (2024)
Lyndsey Wong LA Nurse LA Nurse See fewer	Puppy Love (II) (2023)
Johnny V Wright Parole judge Parole judge See fewer	Secrets on Maple Street (2024)
Wayne Corbeil Court Prosecutor (uncredited) Court Prosecutor (uncredited) See fewer	Scintilla (2023)