Once Upon a Mystery - Cast

Once Upon a Mystery (2025– )
Podcast Series | Fantasy

Once Upon a Mystery (2025– )

Podcast Series | Fantasy

A narrative podcast about a special agent who investigates fairy tales currently in progress to report back to the people that make them into stories.

Seasons

2 | 1 See all

Creator

Seth Chitwood (creator)

Director

Seth Chitwood

Writer

Seth Chitwood

Producers

Jose Cabral (producer) | Seth Chitwood (producer) | Jared Robinson (producer)

See all filmmakers & crew

Become a member to see MOVIEmeter and news information about Once Upon a Mystery.

Edit Released

Updated Nov 3, 2025

Release date (First episode)

Nov 3, 2025 (United States)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for Once Upon a Mystery.

Cast	+ Add Cast
18 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Becky Bass Agent Jessica Valiant Agent Jessica Valiant See fewer	10	Love Undone (2021)
Sean Patrick LaFontaine Doctor Doctor See fewer	3	Once Upon a Mystery (2025)
Curtis Reid The Fool The Fool See fewer	2	World's Worst Holiday Series (2024)
Colin Kinsella The Hunk The Hunk See fewer	2	Amber Oak (2023)
Karen Ann Martino Baker's Wife Baker's Wife See fewer	1	The Girl in the Attic (2016)
Alexa Hartman Silly Triplets Silly Triplets See fewer	1	Luna, the Witch (2020)
Jack O'Hara Prince Prince See fewer	1	Breaking Girl Code (2023)
Michael Maggiani Bookseller Bookseller See fewer	1	Lightkeepers (2022)
Phil Harris Baker Baker See fewer	1	Itch! (2024)
Laina Simone Bartender Bartender See fewer	1	The Starfish
Patti Mendes Elaine Elaine See fewer	1	World's Worst Holiday Series (2024)
Brendan Kenahan Merchant Merchant See fewer	1	The Chronicles of Hope Man (2016)
Ryk Mcyntire Constable Constable See fewer	1	Once Upon a Mystery (2025)
Nina Little The Inventor's Daughter The Inventor's Daughter See fewer	1	Once Upon a Mystery (2025)
Pamela Jayne Morgan Actress Actress See fewer	1	The Holdovers (2023)
Paul Noonan Actor Actor See fewer	1	Godfather of Harlem (2019)
Catherine Hunter Actress Actress See fewer	1	Runaway (II)
Frank O'Donnell Actor Actor See fewer	1	In the Bedroom (2014)