Name	Known for
Eric Foner Self - Historian, Columbia University Self - Historian, Columbia University See fewer	Free State of Jones (2016)
Mark Lee Gardner Self - Author, Shot All to Hell Self - Author, Shot All to Hell See fewer	Expedition Unknown (2015)
Robert Redford Self - Actor, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid Self - Actor, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid See fewer	The Natural (1984)
Larry T. Pourier Self - Oglala Lakota Filmmaker Self - Oglala Lakota Filmmaker See fewer	The New World (2005)
Karl Jacoby Self - Historian, Columbia University Self - Historian, Columbia University See fewer	The Strange Career of William Ellis
H.W. Brands Self - Historian, University of Texas at Austin Self - Historian, University of Texas at Austin See fewer	The American West (2016)
David Eisenbach Self - Historian Self - Historian See fewer	Custer: The Final Mystery (2018)
Kiefer Sutherland Self Self See fewer	24 (2001)
Paul A. Hutton Self - Historian, University of New Mexico (as Paul Hutton) Self - Historian, University of New Mexico (as Paul Hutton) See fewer	Naked Gun 33 1/3: The Final Insult (1994)
Bert Thomas Morris Narrator Narrator See fewer	BoardRoom (2012)
David H. Stevens Jesse James (as David Stevens) Jesse James (as David Stevens) See fewer	The Crow: Salvation (2000)
Will Strongheart Crazyhorse Crazyhorse See fewer	Indian Horse (2017)
Mo Brings Plenty Sitting Bull Sitting Bull See fewer	Yellowstone (2018)
Morgan Lund Ulysses S. Grant Ulysses S. Grant See fewer	The World's Fastest Indian (2005)
John C. Bailey George Custer George Custer See fewer	Within the Darkness (2016)
Jonathan C. Stewart Wyatt Earp Wyatt Earp See fewer	The Making of the Mob (2015)
Derek Chariton Billy the Kid Billy the Kid See fewer	NCIS (2003)
Eric Rolland Thomas Durant Thomas Durant See fewer	The Men Who Built America (2012)
Mike Marunde William T. Sherman (as Michael Marunde) William T. Sherman (as Michael Marunde) See fewer	Harriet (I) (2019)
Joseph Carlson Frank James Frank James See fewer	Lincoln (2012)
Ric Maddox Pat Garrett Pat Garrett See fewer	Dead Men (2018)
Kera O'Bryon Zerelda James Zerelda James See fewer	The American West (2016)
Jim Jackman Rutherford B. Hayes Rutherford B. Hayes See fewer	Spaceballs (1987)
Hugh Scully Allan Pinkerton Allan Pinkerton See fewer	The World Wars (2014)
Mike Anderson Express Messenger #2 Express Messenger #2 See fewer	The American West (2016)
Nick Bialis Morgan Earp (as Nicholas Bialis) Morgan Earp (as Nicholas Bialis) See fewer	The American West (2016)
Sidney Blackmer Jr. Sheriff Moss (as Sudney Blackmer) Sheriff Moss (as Sudney Blackmer) See fewer	Banshee (2013)
Roger Blomquist Brewer (as Roger Bloomquist) Brewer (as Roger Bloomquist) See fewer	Hereditary (2018)
Seth Andrew Bridges Beligerent Cowboy Beligerent Cowboy See fewer	The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live (2024)
Sean M. Brown Cole Younger (as Sean Brown) Cole Younger (as Sean Brown) See fewer	America's First D-Day: Washington's Crossing (2014)
Nick Bloxsom-Carter North Plains Soldier (as Nick Bloxsom Carter) North Plains Soldier (as Nick Bloxsom Carter) See fewer	Muddy Corman (2016)
Jay Cerrado Buffalo Hunter #2 Buffalo Hunter #2 See fewer	The American West (2016)
Michael Chmiel Ike Clanton Ike Clanton See fewer	Clean Break (II) (2014)
Marty Collins Tunstall Tunstall See fewer	Deadstream (2022)
Deborah Lee Douglas Actress Actress See fewer	Alienate (2016)
Benny Gibson Outlaw horseman Outlaw horseman See fewer	The Postman (1997)
Jake Kantor Clerk Clerk See fewer	The Food That Built America (2019)
Isabela Osorio Native American Girl Native American Girl See fewer	The American West (2016)
Dom DiMercurio Pinkerton Lawman (uncredited) Pinkerton Lawman (uncredited) See fewer	Kingpin (2018)
Mark Falvo Cowboy in Saloon (uncredited) Cowboy in Saloon (uncredited) See fewer	The Irishman (2019)
Adam Jones Daniel Askew (uncredited) Daniel Askew (uncredited) See fewer	Hatfields & McCoys (2012)
Benjamin Loeh Bob Younger (uncredited) Bob Younger (uncredited) See fewer	The Last Cry (2019)
Marshall Dancing Elk Lucas Elder / Zone 1 (uncredited) Elder / Zone 1 (uncredited) See fewer	On Sacred Ground (2023)
Steven E. McKinley Secretary of War (uncredited) Secretary of War (uncredited) See fewer	Redrum (2013)
Joshua David McLerran Billy the Kidd Gang Member (uncredited) Billy the Kidd Gang Member (uncredited) See fewer	Daddy Day Camp (2007)
Glynn Praesel Clel Miller (uncredited) Clel Miller (uncredited) See fewer	Age of the Living Dead (2018)
Jacalyn E. Stanley Townswoman (uncredited) Townswoman (uncredited) See fewer	Vampires in Virginia
Paul Wallis Western Cowboy (uncredited) Western Cowboy (uncredited) See fewer	Creed (II) (2015)
Erik Young Union Soldier (uncredited) Union Soldier (uncredited) See fewer	My Boring Zombie Apocalypse (2015)