Name	Known for
Natasha Hatalsky Detective Christina Elliot Detective Christina Elliot See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Wendy Hartman Detective Rebecca Ellison Detective Rebecca Ellison See fewer	First Signal (2021)
Tony Ramos Wright Father Jacob Hamblin Father Jacob Hamblin See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Kathryn Shasha Agent Cable Agent Cable See fewer	Sex Drive (2008)
John Samela Chief Hudson Chief Hudson See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Susan Waletkus Detective Penelope Grant Detective Penelope Grant See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Luisa Maria Badaracco Catherine Hamblin Catherine Hamblin See fewer	Joy (I) (2015)
Jonathan Sartell Dylan Hamblin Dylan Hamblin See fewer	The Girl in the Attic (2016)
Karen Ann Martino Mother Turner (credit only) Mother Turner (credit only) See fewer	The Girl in the Attic (2016)
Herlín Areniello Agent Ruth (as Herlin Navarro) Agent Ruth (as Herlin Navarro) See fewer	Honest Thief (2020)
Ellie Ash Girl in Park Girl in Park See fewer	Where Is She? (II) (2019)
Lorrie Bacon D.A Caroline Kinger D.A Caroline Kinger See fewer	The Love Triangle (2015)
Amanda Callaghan Student Student See fewer	Among Wolves (III) (2015)
Richard Chandler Nathan Nathan See fewer	Gilgamesh (2014)
Hannah Coppolelli Girl Girl See fewer	Almost Mercy (2015)
Jonah Coppolelli Boy Boy See fewer	Agent Toby Barks (2020)
Damon D'Amico Jr. Isaac Isaac See fewer	Slender Man (I) (2018)
Kate Depetro Student Student See fewer	Seeds (I) (2018)
Christie Devine Assistant Assistant See fewer	Wallie's Gals (2023)
Gia Dill Church Member Church Member See fewer	The Resurrection of Victoria Wheeler (2020)
Avery Evans Lilly Elliot Lilly Elliot See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Andrew Faria Patrick Patrick See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Eddie Frateschi Detective Edwards Detective Edwards See fewer	Slender Man (I) (2018)
Adriana Graca Child Child See fewer	The Trees Have Eyes (2020)
Louise Hawko Records Keeper Records Keeper See fewer	Permanent (2014)
Louisa Lamarre Officer Officer See fewer	The Ungovernable Force (2015)
Rachael Marandett Church Patron Church Patron See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Lissette Marroquin Church Patron Church Patron See fewer	Family Problems (2013)
Randy Morris Detective Detective See fewer	A Mothers Greed
Michaelah Noelle Nunes Carol Carol See fewer	Caped Crusader: The Dark Hours (2014)
Deirdre Robins Felecia Felecia See fewer	Friction (2016)
Bless Robinson Records Keeper Records Keeper See fewer	Midnight Butterflies
Ann Williams Teacher Teacher See fewer	Family Problems (2013)