Name	Known for
Paula Zahn Self - Host Self - Host See fewer	Murphy Brown (1988)
Janice Nugent Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer
LeAnne Coryell Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer
Scott Bowles Self - Tipster Self - Tipster See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Raymond Brenkert Ray Ray See fewer	The Eyes (I) (2016)
Jerry Fernandez Self - Janice's Son Self - Janice's Son See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Bob Holland Self - Detective, Tampa Police Department Self - Detective, Tampa Police Department See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Ray Lamar Johnston Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer
John McCarthy Self - Janice's Son-In-Law Self - Janice's Son-In-Law See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Kelli McCarthy Self - Janice's Daughter Self - Janice's Daughter See fewer	They/Them (2022)
Amelie McKendry Janice Nugent Janice Nugent See fewer	Mystic Christmas (2023)
Sandi Morris Self - LeAnne's Mother Self - LeAnne's Mother See fewer	One on One (2019)
Tom Morris Self - LeAnne's Father Self - LeAnne's Father See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Rick Stanton Self - Tampa Police Department (as Detective Rick Stanton) Self - Tampa Police Department (as Detective Rick Stanton) See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)
Mike Willette Self - Detective, Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office Self - Detective, Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office See fewer	On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)