Name	Known for
Doug Walker Self Self See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Malcolm Ray Self Self See fewer	Demo Reel (2012)
Brett Bonynge Self Self See fewer	A Beautiful View of Nothing (2014)
Robbie Allen Bob Bob See fewer	The Redeemer (2019)
Alyssa Jackson Barbara Barbara See fewer	Cutting It Klose
Tamara Chambers Dolores Dolores See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Paul Rohan Ben Ben See fewer	Pair Down (2019)
Jimmy Melf Actor Actor See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Harry Locke IV Julio Julio See fewer	The Redeemer (2019)
James Jarosz Rolly the Fox / Practitioner Rolly the Fox / Practitioner See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Heather Reusz Atlantis Somerset Atlantis Somerset See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Nick La Banca Nautical Nineties Narrator Nautical Nineties Narrator See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Justin Hoffman 'Spin My Helm' Singer 'Spin My Helm' Singer See fewer	Hi, My Name is Justin (2024)
McKane Searle 'Spin My Helm' Bassist 'Spin My Helm' Bassist See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
James Banasiak 'Spin My Helm' Drummer 'Spin My Helm' Drummer See fewer	I'm Still Here (2009)
Alexis Banasiak Waving Woman 1 Waving Woman 1 See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Mooog Waving Woman 2 Waving Woman 2 See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Rob Scallon Waving Man Waving Man See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Catheryn Kuhar Sailor Girl Sailor Girl See fewer	Be Our Guest (2024)
Danny Grenchik 'Shark Weak' Singer 'Shark Weak' Singer See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Trevor Casterline 'Poop Deck Peck' Harmony 1 'Poop Deck Peck' Harmony 1 See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Tom Reusz 'Poop Deck Peck' Harmony 2 'Poop Deck Peck' Harmony 2 See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Aiyanna Wade Wife Wife See fewer	Nostalgia Critic (2007)
Steve Davis Husband Husband See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Joe Banasiak Old Man Old Man See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)
Jim Banasiak Skeleton Skeleton See fewer	Pop Quiz Hotshot (2015)