Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Cast

Cast	+ Add Cast
109 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Galadriel Stineman Cheryl Cooper Cheryl Cooper See fewer	8	LaRoy, Texas (2023)
Denise Gossett Naomi Miller Naomi Miller See fewer	8	Get the Gringo (2012)
Kevin Joy Levi Miller Levi Miller See fewer	8	Truth Be Told (2019)
Riley Beeson Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller Esther Miller - Young Naomi Miller See fewer	8	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise (2025)
Lance E. Nichols Chief Twitchell / Officer Twitchell Chief Twitchell / Officer Twitchell See fewer	8	The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008)
Ryan O'Quinn Seth Miller Seth Miller See fewer	8	Believe (I) (2016)
Lauren Paulis Elizabeth Miller Elizabeth Miller See fewer	7	Invisible Ones
Christophe Farrell Caleb Miller Caleb Miller See fewer	5	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Candace Kirkpatrick Aunt Mitzi Aunt Mitzi See fewer	4	Vindication (2019)
Nick Andrisin Officer Nick Officer Nick See fewer	4	Eenie Meanie (2025)
Kristen Grace Gonzalez Officer Ortega Officer Ortega See fewer	3	Miracle on the Precipice
Amelia Still Lydia Lydia See fewer	3	Always a Winner (2023)
Cat Skugor Renee Police Dispatch (as Catherine Ann Bagent) Renee Police Dispatch (as Catherine Ann Bagent) See fewer	2	The Holiday Club (2024)
Rebecca Lam Podcaster Podcaster See fewer	2	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Andi Anderson Kathy Kathy See fewer	2	Videovore
Charlie Niccolini Thomas Troyer Thomas Troyer See fewer	2	Mixed Signals (III) (2023)
Andy S. Allen Johnson (as Andy Allen) Johnson (as Andy Allen) See fewer	2	How to Rob a Bank (2026)
Joseph Moreland Amos Streeter Amos Streeter See fewer	1	Jesus Land
Paul Anthony McLean Ben and reuben Ben and reuben See fewer	1	The X-Files (1993)
Kristine Beckett Heather Heather See fewer	1	Chocolate for Christmas
Scot Cooper Hunter Ivy Hunter Ivy See fewer	1	Maze Runner: The Death Cure (2018)
Lee Perkins Issac Bracher Issac Bracher See fewer	1	Reptile (2023)
Parker Mack Bill Bill See fewer	1	Ouija: Origin of Evil (2016)
Taylor Snapp Voice of Broadway Pizza Voice of Broadway Pizza See fewer	1	Mindcage (2022)
Samantha Clifford Matilda Tryer Matilda Tryer See fewer	1	The Space Between (II) (2024)
Farrah Rawlings Young Ellen Young Ellen See fewer	1	Specter Predators (2024)
Nate Blair Moses Moses See fewer	1	Alien Apocalypse (2023)
Ena O'Rourke Catherine Ivey Catherine Ivey See fewer	1	Yellow Bird (2023)
Denise Marie Whalen Mrs. Lehman Mrs. Lehman See fewer	1	Julie & Julia (2009)
Michael E Spitz Mr. Girndt (as Michael Spitz) Mr. Girndt (as Michael Spitz) See fewer	1	Dual Mania (2020)
David Gaylor Wendall Wendall See fewer	1	Alan and the Rulers of the Air (2023)
Peggy S. Allen Anna Louise Anna Louise See fewer	1	The Lies We Bury (2025)
Cynthia Collins Beatrice Beatrice See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Sawyer Joy Samuel Samuel See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Rose Agona Ellen Ellen See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Melissa Ordway Lacey Lacey See fewer	1	17 Again (2009)
Brendan Guy Murphy Luke Bradshaw Luke Bradshaw See fewer	1	Wastelander (2018)
Justin Gaston Michael Neal Michael Neal See fewer	1	God's Country Song (2023)
Leah Bateman Cassie Cassie See fewer	1	Where Were You
Meggan Kaiser Sarah Sarah See fewer	1	A Missed Connection (2024)
Rebecca Koon Della Della See fewer	1	Radio (2003)
Michelle Neil Ginny Cooper Ginny Cooper See fewer	1	Valentine's Town (2024)
Joseph Gray Lance Lance See fewer	1	Dark Resonance (2016)
Darby Cappillino Ruthanna Ruthanna See fewer	1	Lifeless: A Musical Zomedy (2023)
Mark de Jeu Chuck Chuck See fewer	1	Sammi Girl (2015)
Phillip Abraham Matt Cooper Matt Cooper See fewer	1	Ballers (2015)
Karen M. Chan Fannie Borntrager Fannie Borntrager See fewer	1	I Can (I) (2023)
Laurie Coker Agnes Agnes See fewer	1	Esperanza (II) (2021)
Sheila Ball Suzanne Marshall Suzanne Marshall See fewer	1	American Trash (2024)
Lainie Smith Maybelline Maybelline See fewer	1	A Fish That Walked (2025)
Terry Tocantins Dale Dale See fewer	1	Checkmate (I) (2025)
Jacob Kaufman Michael Borland Michael Borland See fewer	1	Who's Stalking My Family (2024)
Christine Oswald Amalie Amalie See fewer	1	American Dynasty (2022)
Matt Zehnder Jeff Srockton Jeff Srockton See fewer	1	This is Business (2009)
Alan Cupp Leonard Raber Leonard Raber See fewer	1	Obscura (I) (2012)
Don Stuck Henry King Henry King See fewer	1	American Greed (2007)
Renee Krapff Wendy Wendy See fewer	1	The Lies We Bury (2025)
Delaney Hathaway Carolyn Caldwell Carolyn Caldwell See fewer	1	Straight and Narrow (2020)
Nathan Leonard Leroy Leroy See fewer	1	Dewey Days
Ben Teitelbaum Henry Henry See fewer	1	Saturday Night Live (1975)
Andrae Todd James Bicy Agent Riggins Agent Riggins See fewer	1	Catfish Christmas (2022)
Suzanne Jennings Linda havens Linda havens See fewer	1	Eleanor's Bench (2023)
Douglas K. Harrison Irving Borntrager Irving Borntrager See fewer	1	Hope's Hollywood Christmas (2024)
Barbara Nuss Stiles Velma Velma See fewer	1	O&0 (2024)
Albert Dan Armstrong III Frank Raber Frank Raber See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Callie Bussell Jessica Stockton Jessica Stockton See fewer	1	Thy Will Be Done (2025)
Michael Alan Herman Jakob Jakob See fewer	1	Monster (2022)
Owen Phillips Elam Troyer Elam Troyer See fewer	1	Murder, Lies and Marriage (2025)
Elizabeth Becka Evelyn Evelyn See fewer	1	She-Hulk: Attorney at Law (2022)
Elizabeth Thomakos Rose King Rose King See fewer	1	Old Fashioned (2014)
John Capocci Mickey Simmons Mickey Simmons See fewer	1	Gnashing in Gehenna
Jaime Price Morphy Joanna Troyer Joanna Troyer See fewer	1	Murder Inside of Me (2009)
Rusty James Emmon Emmon See fewer	1	E-Bowla (2018)
Angela Katherine Baker Pam Pam See fewer	1	Fighting the Fire (2024)
Deanna Rowland Angela - Director of Woman's Shelter Angela - Director of Woman's Shelter See fewer	1	Red Blooded (2023)
Daniel Repas Saul Troyer Saul Troyer See fewer	1	The Hunting (2021)
John Basler Locksmith Locksmith See fewer	1	The Desperate
Kevin Lingle Greg Cooper Greg Cooper See fewer	1	Queen of the Ring (2024)
Teri Lee Woman at Shelter Woman at Shelter See fewer	1	Young Harvest (2013)
Roxie Long Ethyl Ethyl See fewer	1	Grim (IX)
Tia Santamaria Marion Marion See fewer	1	Happy Sorrows (2026)
Deaton Gabbard Brandt Brandt See fewer	1	Earthquake Underground (2024)
Lawson Touliatos Mark Troyer Mark Troyer See fewer	1	It's Christmas Again (2022)
Caleb Jackson Agent McGraw Agent McGraw See fewer	1	Chameleon (I) (2024)
Kathy A. Bates Clara Raber Clara Raber See fewer	1	The Lies We Bury (2025)
Lorraine Knox Quilt Shop Customer Quilt Shop Customer See fewer	1	A Carpenter's Prayer (2024)
Taylor Rice Borland's Receptionist Borland's Receptionist See fewer	1	The Cat in the Hat (2003)
Theresa Wylie Barbara Barbara See fewer	1	Hi (2013)
Holly Anspaugh Judge Judge See fewer	1	Chicago Med (2015)
Laurie Ann Pickard Mary Mary See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Maria Seibert Customer #1 Customer #1 See fewer	1	Mr. Manhattan (2024)
Mariane Hughes Miriam Miriam See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Ryan Michael Smith Stephen Raber Stephen Raber See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Timon Emch Chandler Smith Chandler Smith See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Maggie Lou Rader Alex Alex See fewer	1	White Noise (I) (2022)
Joanna Leigh Burden Ruth Ruth See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Noah Beachy Gage Gage See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Charone Frankel Customer #2 Customer #2 See fewer	1	Shooting Stars (2023)
Micah Lynn Hanson Hannah Miller Hannah Miller See fewer	1	A Match Made at Christmas (2021)
Elliott Wortley Drake Drake See fewer	1	Hometown Spirit (2022)
Stephen Blackwell Blake Blake See fewer	1	Unified Uprising (2025)
Spencer Thomakos Michael's Attorney Michael's Attorney See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Alena Morris Woman on tour Woman on tour See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Joe Kurak Joe Joe See fewer	1	Snatched from the Crib (2025)
Zach Midyett Abel Abel See fewer	1	Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Mikey Rogers Roger Photographer Roger Photographer See fewer	1	Hunted (II) (2023)
Atticus Joy Young Amos Young Amos See fewer	1	Follow Your Heart (2020)
Hayden Woolsey Young Seth Miller Young Seth Miller See fewer		Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)
Lainie Smith Maybelline (as Laraine Smith) Maybelline (as Laraine Smith) See fewer		Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)

There was an issue loading this tab.

Contacts

Cast

MOVIEmeter

MAIN MENU

YOUR TOOLS

YOUR ACCOUNT

IMDbPro