Name	Known for
Johnny Bonds Self - Homicide Investigator Self - Homicide Investigator See fewer	Prosecuting Evil with Kelly Siegler (2023)
Dawn Bright Self - Erika's Friend Self - Erika's Friend See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Mary Brown Self - Erika's Sister Self - Erika's Sister See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Jury Case Sr. Self - Erika's Father Self - Erika's Father See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Isaiah Dooley Self - Suspect Self - Suspect See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Derek Fell Self - Vigo County Sheriff's Department (as Det. Derek Fell) Self - Vigo County Sheriff's Department (as Det. Derek Fell) See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Penny Garriott Self - Clint's Friend Self - Clint's Friend See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Jennifer Kalber Self - Clint's Ex-Girlfriend Self - Clint's Ex-Girlfriend See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Clint Mackey Self - Suspect Self - Suspect See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Robert Mackey Self - Clint's Grandfather Self - Clint's Grandfather See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Yolanda McClary Self - Crime Scene Investigator Self - Crime Scene Investigator See fewer	TNT Cold Justice: The Odds (2017)
Amanda Michaels Self - Jenny Lee's Sister Self - Jenny Lee's Sister See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Tiffany Miller Self - Witness Self - Witness See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
John Moats Self - Vigo County Sheriff's Department (as Cpt. John Moats) Self - Vigo County Sheriff's Department (as Cpt. John Moats) See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Terry Modesitt Self - Vigo County Prosecutor's Office (as Prosecutor Terry Modesitt) Self - Vigo County Prosecutor's Office (as Prosecutor Terry Modesitt) See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Robert Roberts Self - Vigo County Prosecutor's Office (as Chief Dep. Prosecutor Robert Roberts) Self - Vigo County Prosecutor's Office (as Chief Dep. Prosecutor Robert Roberts) See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)
Kelly Siegler Self - Prosecutor Self - Prosecutor See fewer	TNT Cold Justice: The Odds (2017)
Steve Spingola Self - Homicide Investigator Self - Homicide Investigator See fewer	Cold Justice (2013)