Already a subscriber?
Log In
Cast | + Add Cast |
| 48 cast members |
| Name | Known for |
|---|---|
Melissa Cann
Self - Sister of Maureen Brainard-Barnes
|
|
Robert Kolker
Self - Author, Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery
|
|
Stuart Cameron
Self - Inspector, Suffolk County PD
|
|
Jaclyn Gallucci
Self - Journalist, Long Island Press
|
|
John Ray
Self - Attorney for Mari Gilbert
|
|
Gus Garcia-Roberts
Self - Author, Jimmy the King
|
|
Elizabeth Meserve
Self - Aunt of Megan Waterman
|
|
Steve Bellone
Self - Suffolk County Executive 2012 - 2023
|
|
Rob Trotta
Self - Detective, Suffolk County Police Dept.
|
|
Geraldine Hart
Self - Senior Agent, Long Island FBI
|
|
Timothy Sini
Self - Suffolk County Police Commissioner 2015 - 2017
|
|
John Olivia
Self - Detective, Suffolk County Police Dept.
|
|
Nikkie Brass
Self - Former Long Island Sex Worker
|
|
Amanda Funderburg
Self - Sister of Melissa Barthelemy
|
|
Dave Schaller
Self - Friend of Amber Costello
|
|
Bear Brodsky
Self - Friend of Amber Costello
|
|
Melissa Barthelemy
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Maureen Brainard-Barnes
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Amber Costello
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Shannan Gilbert
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Jessica Taylor
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Megan Waterman
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Valerie Mack
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Lynn Barthelemy
Self - Mother of Melissa Barthelemy (archive footage)
|
|
Lorraine Ela
Self - Mother of Megan Waterman (archive footage)
|
|
Mari Gilbert
Self - Mother of Shannan Gilbert (archive footage)
|
|
John Pius
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
John Bittrolff
Self - Convicted Killer (archive footage)
|
|
Sandra Costilla
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Colleen McNamee
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Rita Tangredi
Self - Murder Victim (archive footage)
|
|
Michael Baden
Self - Forensic Pathologist (archive footage) (as Dr. Michael Baden)
|
|
James Burke
Self - Chief of Department, Suffolk County Police Dept. (archive footage)
|
|
Robert Capers
Self - US Attorney for Eastern District of New York (archive footage)
|
|
Richard Dormer
Self - Suffolk County Police Commissioner (archive footage)
|
|
Sara Karnes
Self - Maureen“s Friend (archive footage)
|
|
Christopher Loeb
Self - Petty Criminal (archive footage)
|
|
Thomas Spota
Self - Suffolk County District Attorney (archive footage) (as Thomas J. Spota)
|
|
Maria Alessi
Melissa (uncredited)
|
|
Anthony Altieri
Detective (uncredited)
|
|
Raquel Fernandez
Amber (uncredited)
|
|
Lorian Gish
Nikkie (uncredited)
|
|
Maya Goren
Amanda (uncredited)
|
|
Greg Hoffman
Law enforcement (uncredited)
|
|
Char Jones
Megan (uncredited)
|
|
Aaron Peck
Detective (uncredited)
|
|
Nate Terani
Rex (uncredited)
|
|
Isabella Victorson
Maureen (uncredited)
|