Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction The Third Date/The Legend of the Headless Horseman/Mr. Chang's Shop/Lucky Loser/Prey (Season 5, Episode 1)
TV Episode | Mystery, Thriller, Fantasy

Primary photo for The Third Date/The Legend of the Headless Horseman/Mr. Chang's Shop/Lucky Loser/Prey

Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction

The Third Date/The Legend of the Headless Horseman/Mr. Chang's Shop/Lucky Loser/Prey (Season 5, Episode 1)

TV Episode | Mystery, Thriller, Fantasy

A mysterious bartender serves a blue cocktail. A headless horseman roams the streets. A lucky guy has divine help. A woman saves a shop owner from a robbery. A hickey proves to be deadly.

Showrunner

Holger Frick (segments: The Third Date)

Head writer

Bernd Blaschke

Directors

Lara Aslanian (segments: Guardian Angel, Lucky Loser) | Holger Frick (segments: Mr. Chang's Shop) | Renato Novakovic (segments: Headless Horseman, The Hickey)

Writers

Bernd Blaschke | Marc Cushman (segments: Headless Horseman) | Holger Frick (segments: The Third Date) | Steffen Hacker (segments: The Hickey) & 5 more

Cinematographer

Editor

Casting Director

Production Designer

See all filmmakers & crew (27)

Edit Released

Updated Oct 30, 2022

Release date

Oct 30, 2022 (Germany)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for The Third Date/The Legend of the Headless Horseman/Mr. Chang's Shop/Lucky Loser/Prey.

Cast	+ Add Cast
8 cast members

Name	Known for
Andrew Biernat Theo Theo See fewer	The Black Dagger Brotherhood (2025)
Jonathan Frakes Self - Host Self - Host See fewer	Star Trek: First Contact (1996)
Braxton Hale Robber Robber See fewer	Law & Order (1990)
Grant S. Johnson Headless Horseman Headless Horseman See fewer	Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction (1997)
Ben Scattone Deputy Deputy See fewer	Cotton Candy Bubble Gum (2025)
Martin Thompson Sheriff Dallas Sheriff Dallas See fewer	Wanderlust (2012)
Mitch Ward Phil Phil See fewer	Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction (1997)
Erin Wu Clarice Clarice See fewer	Sugar (2024)