Indiana Unsolved's primary photo

Still A Mystery

Indiana Unsolved (Season 5, Episode 3)
TV Episode | Crime
Two stories are outlined. 1. On September 28, 2015, 20-year-old Joseph W. Smedley II, a student at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, sends his sister Vivianne Bernas a cryptic message about leaving town to move overseas. Three ...See moreTwo stories are outlined. 1. On September 28, 2015, 20-year-old Joseph W. Smedley II, a student at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, sends his sister Vivianne Bernas a cryptic message about leaving town to move overseas. Three days later on October 2, 2015, his body is found in Griffy Lake, weighted down by a backpack filled with 66 pounds of rocks. The authorities declare the case to be a suicide, but the family disagrees. The family has not had adequate access to the police files and are still looking for answers. 2. On July 6, 2004, 22-year-old Molly Laura Dattilo of Indianapolis, Indiana disappeared. She was last seen with John Shelton, a violent man with a prison record who is a person of interest, along with John's father, Edward Shelton. In October 2008, a caller to a tip line shared information that John Shelton told his father Edward Shelton that he had "accidentally" killed a girl. The family members sued John Shelton in civil court and won their case. However, they still do not have answers about what happened and the police do not have enough evidence to further the case. Molly Dattilo was legally declared dead, but the family still wants answers. Written by Suzanne See less
Read more: Plot summary
Editor
Nathan McCormick
See all filmmakers & crew (8)
Status
Edit Released
Updated Sep 18, 2022
Release date
Sep 18, 2022 (United States)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for Indiana Unsolved.

Cast

 + Add Cast
13 cast members
Name Known for
Andrew McPherson's primary photo
Andrew McPherson
Narrator (voice) Narrator (voice)   See fewer
In the Red (1999)
Stacy Bridavsky's primary photo
Stacy Bridavsky
Self - Podcast Host Self - Podcast Host   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Vivianne Bernas's primary photo
Vivianne Bernas
Self - Joseph's Sister Self - Joseph's Sister   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Amy Coursey's primary photo
Amy Coursey
Self - Host of Cold Case Chronicles Self - Host of Cold Case Chronicles   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Ben Dattilo's primary photo
Ben Dattilo
Self - Molly's Father Self - Molly's Father   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Keri Dattilo's primary photo
Keri Dattilo
Self - Molly's Cousin Self - Molly's Cousin   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Molly Dattilo's primary photo
Molly Dattilo
Self - Murder Victim in 2006 / Age 22 (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim in 2006 / Age 22 (archive footage)   See fewer
Wilbur Dattilo's primary photo
Wilbur Dattilo
Self - Molly's Brother Self - Molly's Brother   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Celestra Dewey's primary photo
Celestra Dewey
Self - Molly's Sister Self - Molly's Sister   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Joseph Smedley II's primary photo
Joseph Smedley II
Self - Joseph's Father Self - Joseph's Father   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
Joseph Smedley III's primary photo
Joseph Smedley III
Self - Possible Homicide in 2015 / Age 20 (archive footage) Self - Possible Homicide in 2015 / Age 20 (archive footage)   See fewer
Chance Walser's primary photo
Chance Walser
Self - Reporter (archive footage) Self - Reporter (archive footage)   See fewer
Andrea Zaferes's primary photo
Andrea Zaferes
Self - Aquatic Death Investigator Self - Aquatic Death Investigator   See fewer
Still A Mystery (2018)
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.
There was an issue loading this tab.

MOVIEmeter

Members only

Become a member to access additional data

Ratings Breakdown

+ Add external reviews