Name	Known for
Thom Reed Self - Primary Witness Self - Primary Witness See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Nancy Reed Self - Thom Reed's Mother - Key Witness Self - Thom Reed's Mother - Key Witness See fewer	Inducted (2023)
Jane Green Self - Retired Business Owner Self - Retired Business Owner See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Tom Warner Self - Great Barrington Resident Self - Great Barrington Resident See fewer	Beyond the Stars - the Tom Warner story
Melanie Kirchdorfer Self - Local Business Owner Self - Local Business Owner See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Jane Shaw Self - Great Barrington Resident Self - Great Barrington Resident See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Tom Jay Self - Broadcaster, WSBS Radio 1942 - 2012 (archive footage) Self - Broadcaster, WSBS Radio 1942 - 2012 (archive footage) See fewer
Jesse Stuart Self - Brand Manager, WSBS Radio Self - Brand Manager, WSBS Radio See fewer	Inducted (2023)
William Walsh Self - Great Barrington Police Department (as Chief William Walsh) Self - Great Barrington Police Department (as Chief William Walsh) See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Gary Leveille Self - Berkshire County Historian Self - Berkshire County Historian See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Eddie Gulotta Self - Owner, Gulotta's Gas Self - Owner, Gulotta's Gas See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)
Santi Gulotta Self - Sheffield Police Department (archive footage) (as Chief Santi Gulotta) Self - Sheffield Police Department (archive footage) (as Chief Santi Gulotta) See fewer
Ursula Anderman Nancy Reed - Thom Reed's Mother Nancy Reed - Thom Reed's Mother See fewer	Terrifier (2016)
Luke Isaksen Tom Warner (young) Tom Warner (young) See fewer	Unsolved Mysteries (2020)