Unusual Suspects Elemental Murder (Season 3, Episode 10)
TV-14
TV Episode | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

Unusual Suspects

Elemental Murder (Season 3, Episode 10)

TV-14

TV Episode | 44 min | Documentary, Crime

When a hardworking waitress ingests a lethal dose of poison, a nationwide panic ensues. Everyone is a suspect, until one of the most bizarre sting operations in Florida history leads detectives to the implausible poisoner.

Director

Writer

Composer

Cinematographer

Editors

Keith Baker | Steven J. Escobar (as Steven Escobar) | Lisa Ginsburg | Bradley Holmes

See all filmmakers & crew (50)

Edit Released

Updated May 6, 2012

Release date

May 6, 2012 (United States)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for Elemental Murder.

Cast	+ Add Cast
15 cast members

Name	Known for
Donna Rusch Peggy Carr Peggy Carr See fewer	Gone Girl (2014)
John Aguero Self - Prosecutor, 10th Judicial Circuit Self - Prosecutor, 10th Judicial Circuit See fewer	Forensic Files (1996)
Kenny Apel George Trepal George Trepal See fewer	Insight (2021)
Dave Bean Homicide Detective Homicide Detective See fewer	Mrs. Fitzgerald Is Missing (2017)
Peggy Carr Self - Victim (archive footage) Self - Victim (archive footage) See fewer
Kaela Comontofski Cissy Carr Cissy Carr See fewer	Solvent (2015)
Duane Dubberly Self - Peggy Carr's Son Self - Peggy Carr's Son See fewer	Vengeance: Killer Neighbors (2019)
T. Richard Hostler Self - M.D., Neurologist Self - M.D., Neurologist See fewer	Unusual Suspects (2010)
Chrystal Skye Jordan Tammy Carr Tammy Carr See fewer	Rise of the Undead (2005)
Grady Judd Self - Sheriff, Polk County, Florida (as Sheriff Grady Judd) Self - Sheriff, Polk County, Florida (as Sheriff Grady Judd) See fewer	Takedown with Chris Hansen (2022)
Sandra R. Kisling Diana Trepal Diana Trepal See fewer	The Heartbreak Kid (2007)
Mocean Melvin Self - Narrator (voice) Self - Narrator (voice) See fewer	Dead Air (I) (2009)
Suzie Schottelkotte Self - Senior Reporter, The Ledger Self - Senior Reporter, The Ledger See fewer	Vengeance: Killer Neighbors (2019)
George Trepal Self - Suspect (archive footage) Self - Suspect (archive footage) See fewer
Adam Wagner Det. Ernie Mincey Det. Ernie Mincey See fewer	Charlotta-TS (2010)